Erasmus Prize 2004 awarded
to Sadik
Jalal Al-Azm, Fatema
Mernissi and
Abdulkarim Soroush

The Patron, H.R.H. Prince
Bernhard of the Netherlands, and Board of the Praemium Erasmianum
Foundation, have decided to award the Erasmus Prize 2004 to Sadik Jalal
Al-Azm (Syria), Fatema Mernissi (Morocco) and Abdulkarim Soroush (Iran).
The Erasmus Prize is awarded
annually to a person or institution that has made an exceptionally
important contribution to European culture, society or social science. The
amount of the Prize is € 150.000. The presentation of the Prize will take
place in the autumn of 2004 in Amsterdam.
'Religion and Modernity' is the
subject of the Erasmus Prize 2004. Recent global developments in the
political and social sphere have given new impetus to the societal and
intellectual debate on the relationship between religion and modernity. In
this debate the question is raised of what is the position of religion
with regard to modernisation processes in society, processes such as
knowledge development, secularisation, individualisation and
democratisation.
At present it is especially modernisation processes in relation to Islam,
which attract attention worldwide. One of the central questions concerns
the attitude of Muslims toward social, political and religious
implications of modernity. What sort of different positions do they take
up with regard to such matters as democracy, separation of church and
state, and human rights, including women's rights? To what extent do they
take inspiration from modern philosophical and cultural movements? Where
do they place the limits of criticism on their own religion and its
traditions and customs? On matters such as these a broad range of opinions
is voiced, varying from highly traditionalist to very enlightened.
In Western Europe, the public debate about Islam and modernity at the same
time also leads to self-reflection. Western Enlightenment, generally
considered the cradle of modernity, is critically being re-examined. For
instance, while raising the question of whether religion should be an
impediment to modernisation, one should realise that modernisation
processes may not always follow the course of models developed in the
West.
Given the broad, general scope of the subject, the Praemium Erasmianum
Foundation wishes to do justice to a diversity of views, to a variety of
themes and to regional differences. For this reason it has decided to
divide the Erasmus Prize 2004 among three laureates. The three laureates
have, each in their own way, occupied themselves with the question of how
modernisation processes and cultures which are permeated by religion can
be combined. They deserve a worldwide audience. In alphabetical order, the
laureates are Sadik Jalal Al-Azm (Syria), Fatema Mernissi (Morocco), and
Abdulkarim Soroush (Iran).
Biographies
Sadik J.
Al-Azm (retired Professor of Modern European Philosophy at the
University of Damascus) was born in Damascus, in 1934, member of a
well-known Sunnite family.
In 1963, after studies at Yale University he lectured philosophy at the
American University of Beirut. Not considering himself a Marxist in
particular, he rather sees himself as a materialistic thinker who in a
practical way deals with the political and social circumstances in which
he finds himself.
Al-Azm became well known with his book Self-criticism after the Defeat
(1968), in which he gives an analysis of the Arab disillusionment after
the Six Days War. Apart from publications in Arabic some of his books
appeared in English translation. Besides, his books were published in
German, Dutch, English, Norwegian and Italian (Unbehagen in der Moderne.
Aufklärung im Islam,1993; Kritiek op godsdienst en wetenschap. Vijf essays
over islamitische cultuur, 1996; L'Illuminismo islamico. Il disagio della
civiltà, 2002).
During his career he taught, not only in Damascus and Beirut, but also at
Harvard, Princeton and the University of Hamburg (visiting professor in
1998). In 1990/91 he was fellow at the Wissenschaftskolleg in Berlin. He
stayed as a fellow at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars
in Washington D.C. during 1992-93. He lectured in Antwerp and in Amsterdam
(2003). In 2004 he will be visiting professor at the University of
Antwerp.
In May 2004 he will receive the Dr.-Leopold-Lucas-Preis of the
Evangelical-Theological Faculty of the University of Tübingen.
Select bibliography
Kant's theory of time, New York, Philosophical Library 1967
The Origins of Kant's Arguments in the Antinomies, Oxford,
Clarendon Press 1972
Whitehead's Notions of Order and Freedom, The Personalist: a quarterly
journal of philosophy theology literature 48: 579 (1967)
An-Nakd adh-dhati ba'da al-hazima, Dar al-Tali'a, Beiroet 1968 (=
'Zelfkritiek na de nederlaag')
Naqd al-fikr ad-dini, Dar al-Tali'a, Beiroet 1969 (= 'Kritiek op het
religieuze denken')
The Importance of Being Earnest about Salman Rushdie, Die Welt des
Islams: internationale Zeitschrift für die Entwicklungsgeschichte des
Islams, besonders in der Gegenwart 31:1-49 (1991)
Unbehagen in der Moderne. Aufklärung im Islam, Frankfurt a/M 1993
Islamic fundamentalism reconsidered: a critical outline of problems,
ideas, approaches, South Asia Bulletin. Comparative Studies of
South Asia, Africa and the Middle East XIII: 93-121 (1993); XIV: 73-98
(1994)
Is Islam Secularizable? In P. Koslowski & P. Schenk (Hrsg.), Jahrbuch
für Philosophie des Forschungsinstituts für Philosophie Hannover,
15-24 (1996)
Kritiek op godsdienst en wetenschap. Vijf essays over islamitische
cultuur, Amsterdam 1996
Dhihnijjat at-tahriem; Salman Rushdie wa-hakiekat al-adab, London/Beiroet
1992
= 'De mentaliteit van het tot taboe verklaren; Salman Rushdie en de
waarheid van de literatuur'
= Beyond the Tabooing Mentality: Reading the Satanic Verses, Damascus and
Beirut 1997
An Interview, Arab studies quarterly 19: 113-126 (1997)
Trends in Arab Thought, Journal of Palestine Studies: a quarterly on
Palestinian affairs and the Arab-Israeli conflict 27: 68-80 (1998)
The View from Damascus, New York Review of Books, 15 June 2000
The View from Damascus continued, New York Review of Books, 10
August 2000
Born in Fez (Morocco) in 1940, Fatema
Mernissi studied political sciences at the University of Rabat, the
Sorbonne in Paris and Brandeis University (Massachusetts). She published
several books on the position of women in the rapidly changing Muslim
communities in Morocco. Raised in the harem of a well-to-do businessman in
Fez, she had the possibility to describe this institution from the inside.
In 1975 she published the result of her first fieldwork: Beyond the Veil:
Male-Female Dynamics in Modern Muslim Society. In 1985/87 a revised
edition followed in which she added an extensive consideration on the
social changes that had taken place since her first investigation.
The first books in which she expressly spoke for the emancipation of women
were banned in Morocco. Since then most of her work was originally
published in English or French. It has been translated in many languages
and is widely read, also in Islamic countries. In the 80s of the last
century she directed sociological research for UNESCO, ILO and UNFPA
(Population Fund). This resulted in a book with selected interviews: Doing
daily battle, 1988 (Le Maroc raconté par ses femmes, 1983).
In the mid 90s Fatema Mernissi stopped working on women's issues and
switched to civil society as her major topic. She has served as a member
in many national, pan-Arabic and international forums on women and
development in the Islamic world. Presently she is Lecturer of Sociology
at the Mohammed V University of Rabat, and Research Scholar at the
University Institute of Scientific Research.
In May 2003 Fatema Mernissi received the Príncipe de Asturias Award for
Letters.
Select bibliography
Beyond the Veil: Male-Female Dynamics in Modern Muslim Society,
1975 (rev. 1987)
Le Maroc raconté par ses femmes, 1983
L'amour dans les pays musulmans, 1984
Femmes du Gharb, 1985
Le harem politique, 1987
Shahrazad n'est pas marocaine, 1988 (rev. 1992)
Sultanes oubliées, 1990
La Peur-Modernité, 1992
Women's Rebellion and Islamic Memory, 1993
Dreams of Trespass. Tales of a Harem Girlhood, 1994
Les Aït-Débrouille, 1997
Etes-vous vacciné contre le Harem?, 1998
Scheherazade Goes West, 2001
Abdulkarim Soroush (pseud. of Hossein Dabbagh) was born in Tehran
in 1945. After being trained in Tehran as a pharmacologist and philosopher
he left for the United Kingdom where he studied history and philosophy of
science, particularly the philosophy of Popper and Kuhn. During the months
preceding the Islamitic Revolution of Iran Soroush had a large share in
the gatherings of young muslims, opponents of the Shah's regime, that took
place in the London imam-barah. His book, Dialectical Antagonism, a
compilation of his lectures delivered in the imam-barah, was published in
Iran. When the revolution began, in 1979, Soroush returned to Iran. In the
spring of 1980 Soroush was appointed member of the Council for the
Cultural Revolution, established by Ayatollah Khomeini. In 1982 he left
this council for good and never accepted any governmental offices after
that. Among the subjects he taught in Tehran University and elsewhere the
Islamic mysticism, especially Rumi's Mathnawi, was a major one. Soroush
became member of Iran's Academy of Sciences in 1990. However, he became
gradually more critical of the political role played by the Iranian clergy
and after a few years distanced himself from this role. As a result he not
only became subject to harassment and censorship, but also lost his job
and security and was forced to leave the country for England and Canada in
1996.
In 1990 he and a number of his closest friends founded a monthly magazine
Kiyan which soon became the most visible forum ever for religious
intellectualism. In this magazine he published his most controversial
articles on religious pluralism, hermeneutics, tolerance, clericalism etc.
The magazine was clamped down in 1998 among many other magazines and
newspapers by the direct order of the supreme leader of the Islamic
Republic. About a thousand audio tapes of speeches by Soroush on various
social, political, religious and literary subjects delivered all over the
world are widely in circulation in Iran and elsewhere.
From the year 2000 onwards Abdulkarim Soroush has been a Visiting
Professor in Harvard University teaching Islam and Democracy, Quranic
Studies and Philosophy of Islamic Law. Also a scholar in residence in Yale
University he is currently teaching Islamic Political Philosophy at
Princeton University. For the next academic year he will be a visiting
scholar in the Wissenschaftkolleg in Berlin.
Select bibliography
Dialectical Antagonism (in Farsi), Tehran 1978
Philosophy of History (in Farsi), Tehran 1978
What is Science, what is Philosophy (in Farsi), 11th ed. Tehran 1992
The Restless Nature of the Universe (in Farsi and Turkish), reprint Tehran
1980
Satanic Ideology (in Farsi), 5th ed. Tehran 1994
Knowledge and Value (in Farsi)
Observing the Created: Lectures in Ethics and Human Sciences (in Farsi),
3rd ed. Tehran 1994
The Theoretical Contraction and Expansion of Religion: The Theory of
Evolution of Religious Knowledge (in Farsi), 3rd ed. Tehran 1994
Lectures in the Philosophy of Social Sciences: Hermeneutics in Social
Sciences (in Farsi), Tehran 1995
Sagaciousness, Intellectualism and Pietism (in Farsi), Tehran 1991
The Characteristic of the Pious: A Commentary on Imam Ali's Lecture About
the Pious (in Farsi), 4th ed. Tehran 1996
The Tale of the Lords of Sagacity (in Farsi), 3rd ed. Tehran 1996
Wisdom and Livelihood: A Commentary on Imam Ali's Letter to Imam Hasan (in
Farsi), 2nd ed. Tehran 1994
Sturdier than Ideology (in Farsi), Tehran 1994
The Evolution and Devolution of Religious Knowledge in: Kurzman, Ch. (ed.)
Liberal Islam, Oxford 1998
Political Letters (2 volumes), 1999 (Farsi); 3rd volume in preparation
Reason, Freedom and Democracy in Islam, Essential writings of
Adbolkarim Soroush, translated, edited with a critical introduction
by M. Sadri and A. Sadri, Oxford 2000
Intellectualism and Religious Conviction (in Farsi)
The World we live (in Farsi and Turkish)
The Tale of Love and Servitude (in Farsi)
The definitive edition of Rumi's Mathnavi (in Farsi), 1996
Tolerance and Governance (in Farsi), 1997
Straight Paths, An Essay on religious Pluralism (in Farsi), 1998
Expansion of Prophetic Experience (in Farsi), 1999
The Divine Ethics (in Farsi), 2001
|